Tags

How to Professionally Critique Your Boss at the Annual Review

  • critiqueboss

 

No boss is perfect. But is it a good idea to tell him/her so? After all, you might be setting yourself up for retaliation, or called a complainer. However, there are ways to do it with class and tact. If your supervisor's behavior is hindering productivity, you owe it to yourself, the team and the whole company.

 

Bring notes. At a time when you're calm and objective., write down the points you want to bring up — and stick to them. Speaking off the top of your head, in the heat of the moment, is more likely to cause hurt and anger than any beneficial behavior change.

 

Ask if he/she would like feedback. Prepare your boss for the discussion with a polite lead-in. If he/she just doesn't want to hear criticism at all, or will be insulted no matter how nice and positive you try to be, it's better to back off. If you believe the situation is putting the team or company at risk, handle it another way, such as through HR.

 

Focus on your perceptions. Don't make direct accusations: "You bully us in meetings." Instead, say that this is how you interpreted the behavior, which may not be how your boss intended it. "I feel that you don't value our input in meetings."

 

Stick to specifics. Blanket statements such as, "You're always micromanaging us" are not informative or helpful. Give some examples of occasions when his/her micromanaging delayed production or harmed morale.

 

Put it in terms of his/her goals. You're the one who looks bad when you say, "Your long lunches are forcing us to work late." Instead, say something like, "If you took a shorter lunch, we could get more done and exceed the team's quotas."

 

Make clear that you may not see the whole picture. Sometimes a supervisor's actions are in response to directives or conditions you're not aware of. If he/she is introducing a new way of doing things or a new team organizational structure, explain what you're uneasy about and suggest that more communication from him/her would ease tensions.

 

Don't give an eye for an eye. When you get a negative review, it's tempting to throw responsibility for it back on the boss. "If he gave me more guidance, I wouldn't make so many mistakes." Before you risk ruining your working relationship, take an honest look at yourself. Also, make sure that other people under his supervision also see the problem. Then you'll know it's really him, not you.

 

Critiquing your boss can be scary. But if you approach it the right way, and both of you are open to the process, your relationship will be stronger and more productive than ever.

Tags

You might be interested in...

7.05.18
How to Tell Your Boss No Without Hurting Your Career
"I don't have time to do that." "I think that's a stupid idea." "It's not my job."   When your boss asks you to do something, these answers may be perfectly true, but they're also guaranteed to make him/her angry.   As the saying goes, you catch more flies with honey than with vinegar. Let's see how a more diplomatic wording can get you out of an assignment while staying in your supervisor's good graces.   You really don't have time. The problem with just saying that is the questions it puts in your boss's head: doesn't this employee know how to prioritize tasks or handle a normal workload?   Instead: Ask for help prioritizing your projects. Make sure your boss fully realizes everything you're working on, how long it will take to finish, and what would have to be postponed in order to accomplish the new task.   You don't think it will work. Maybe you've seen this same or similar idea already tried and failed, or it just doesn't seem well thought out....
Read More
2.13.18
5 Ways to Make Your Tax Refund Worth Even More
  So what are you going to do with your tax refund? Take a nice vacation? Buy an iPhone X? Before you decide to spend it on something just for fun, check out these uses that will pay you back with even more money in your pocket.   1. Put it in your emergency fund. Sooner or later, your car will break down, your pet will get sick or some other unexpected expense will blindside you. Having an emergency fund in your bank means you won't have to borrow money to pay the mechanic or vet. So, that tax refund will save you all the interest you would have paid on the loan. Plus, it will save you from extra stress in an already stressful situation.   2. Pay off bank and credit card debt. Do you even know how much interest you're paying every month on your car loan, credit card balances or mortgage? Most people are shocked when they find out. Getting those debts paid down ahead of schedule can save you hundreds or thousands of dollars over the life of the loan — all thanks to your...
Read More
1.19.18
How to Work Well Under Pressure
  It's a question you often hear during a job interview: "Do you work well under pressure?" And of course you answer yes. But what does that even mean? Could you elaborate on your answer if the interviewer asked you to?   Here are some ways to handle stress on the job, and explain it during your interview.   It's all about your attitude. If you see pressure as threatening, your instinct will be to avoid it rather than conquering it. Instead, look at it as a challenge that you'll have fun meeting, and a valuable experience that will help grow your career.   Think about times when you've had to learn a new skill or meet an impossible deadline, and how it has qualified you for a more responsible, rewarding position.   Stay in the present. Worrying about the ultimate success or failure of the process can be overwhelming — and paralyzing. Instead, take it one step at a time.   When star athletes are asked if they're thinking about winning the championship, they...
Read More
General

Title

More Info
You need an account to do that Set up an account Never Mind

Please register for an account first. If you already have one, log in here.